May 26, 2017

A Frozen Moment in Time…

Category: News — Ira @ 5:31 pm


All things belonging to the earth will never change – the leaf,
the blade, the flower, the wind that cries and sleeps and wakes
again, the trees whose stiff arms clash and tremble in the dark,
and the dust of lovers long since buried in the earth…

—Thomas Wolfe

The photo came from nowhere, earlier this week. From my brother Jesse, from his home down south. He must have been rummaging around some old boxes, digging through some memories. And he posted a few pics on the family page on Facebook. A few pictures of scenes from Old Bloomfield, when Jesse and his family visited in 1986. Yes. Interesting. But then he posted the pic that made me sit bolt upright in my seat.

It’s a picture of my parents, Dad and Mom. David and Ida Mae Wagler. A pastoral scene really, on a sunny summer morning. They’re on the concrete walks, coming out of our old house to the east. Jesse snuck the picture from the kitchen window, on the second floor. With a real camera. There were no cell phones with digital cameras back then, that you could hide easily. So Jesse had to snap the photo with a real camera. And the scene he captured struck me hard in a place deep inside my heart. It was a place I had not seen in such a raw and real way in a long, long time.

Dad and Mom (Click to enlarge)
(t almost looks like a painting. You can click it to enlarge. Then click again.)

It’s the most casual of moments, frozen forever in time. And yeah, I know. Every photograph ever taken was a frozen second in time. The difference is this. There are no photos of my childhood world, my Amish world. Or very, very few. And there certainly have been no photos of Dad and Mom in the same scene. Such a thing was just an impossibility, where I grew up. I mean, it’s such a simple thing. Yet so far away. And that’s why it hit me so hard. It’s a scene I have lived and seen and felt a thousand times in real life, a long time ago. But I’ve never relived it, not quite like this.

1986. It was a fateful year for me. A brutal year. A year fraught with memories and nightmares. It was a year where so much came down, on one of the final stages of my long and tortured journey to break free from my people.

I thought they were old, then, my parents. And from my perspective at that moment, I guess they were. Both were gray-haired. Dad limped, and was slightly stooped. Mom, well, Mom was just Mom. Her smile always made her seem young, when she wasn’t, anymore. The astonishing thing is, I’ll be where they both were then, if I live another ten years. There is no new thing under the sun, King Solomon wrote. And it is true. He saw his own journey into old age. As did my parents. And I am approaching the door. It’s all pretty astounding, when you think about it.

Back the picture. 1986. That spring, I fled Bloomfield. After the Stud had passed, and I buried him in the brushy hillside by the creek. After I realized there was nothing left to keep me here. Not even my horse. After I broke my solemn promise to Sarah, to love her and protect her all our lives. And after we sat on the banks of the pond and talked, and after she spun that woven ring I still have today.

That was just the beginning of 1986.

And now, here is an old photograph from that year, a picture I saw for the first time early this week. An old shot of film, from an old camera. A mere fraction of a second, frozen in time. Yet that second in time triggers so many vivid scenes in my mind and memory. Scenes of darkness, and scenes of light.

It was a sunny summer morning, in 1986. And sometime that summer, my brother Jesse had made plans. He would pack up his family and go up to Bloomfield to visit Dad and Mom. A fairly rare occurrence, back then. It took fortitude, for the non-Amish children to even make the effort to go home and visit. Bloomfield was full of Amish bears. Dad was among the fiercest of those bears. It seemed like he grumbled and growled a lot when his wayward children came around.

They preached it, in Bloomfield. I can still hear John Yoder as clearly in my head, as when I heard him shout it in a sermon. When your rebellious children send flowers to their mother, that doesn’t mean there’s any kind of love involved at all. It just means they’re trying to soothe their guilty conscience. They know better. The roses should be rejected. Sent back, or dumped out in the trash. That’s a pretty brutal place to come from. It’s where Dad was in 1986.

So home wasn’t all that warm or welcoming to Jesse and his family. Except for Mom. She loved her children, all alike. And she always, always welcomed them to her home. Her heart was open. I guess that’s probably why Jesse even made any kind of effort to go visit his parents, back then.

He and his wife, Lynda, packed up their family. Loaded up the van, and headed north from their home in Abbeville, SC. It was probably a short trip, time-wise. After two days or so, Dad’s face got noticeably darker. And the air around home got increasingly chilly, even on the hottest summer day. So the “wayward” children never hung around that long. Looking back, I marvel that any of us ever made much of an effort to even go back home. That’s how unwelcoming Dad was. It had to be our Mother’s heart that drew us back. It had to be her openness, her smiles of welcome, her unflinching love.

In 1986, Dad was 65 years old. Young enough to be full of and fire and passion. And suppressed rage, never far below the surface. He knew what he knew. And he believed what he believed. It mattered not to him who got wounded along the way.

And looking at this picture, and how it ever came to be, I can’t help but remember, too. How other non-Amish visitors came around, and what happened. Years before, when we lived in Aylmer, Mom’s father and siblings would come to visit her about once a year, during the summer. They were Block Church people, who drove cars. Dad was always like a dark thunderstorm when they came. They didn’t stay long, maybe a day and two nights. I’m surprised, that they kept coming. I guess it was because they loved my Mom.

And one summer day, they showed up to visit. They always arrived unannounced. I figure they couldn’t tell Mom what they were planning, because she’d be forced to write them not to come. It was what it was. That night, there was a school meeting scheduled in the Aylmer community. Dad was going, which was fine. But he insisted that Mom go with him. To the school meeting, when her Dad and brothers and sisters were there for a brief visit. They were Block Church people, from Daviess. They weren’t worth valuing. Not the time they took to get there, or the time it took to be hospitable. Mom went to the school meeting with Dad that night.

Such was the fire and passion and senseless rage of my father in his younger years. The great writer, the great pontificator, telling others all about how it is to live right. It was a cruel thing for him to do. A harsh and bitter thing. And it was a brutal thing for my Mom to endure. She did it, simply because she had no other choice. I believe the Lord looked down and saw her suffering. And I believe He made sure her story would one day be told to all the world.

Dad was so full of the righteousness of his cause. I am often amazed, that he didn’t force himself to stop and think. Surely he could have looked ahead and seen that at least one of his children would write, as he wrote. At least one child would write what he saw in the world around him, growing up.

Surely Dad could have seen that one day, his children would go and seek out their Mother’s family. And make the connection he had worked so stridently to deny for all those years. It just boggles my mind, how shortsighted he was. So intelligent, and yet so obtuse. He sure didn’t take much time to look very far into the future. Or consider that one day, another story might be told.

He was a deeply flawed man.

The thing I’ve realized is, I’m every bit as flawed as he ever was. Just in different ways.

A bit of a bunny trail, there. I don’t apologize. Back, now, to 1986. And back to the picture.

It was a sunny summer morning. Maybe midmorning. The grass is lush and green. My parents lived alone in the big old house where we had all lived together, years before. So they had plenty of room for company. Marvin and Rhoda lived in a trailer house up the hill to the west. The Dawdy house would be built a few years later, in the north end of Mom’s big garden. In 1986, the big old house stood almost forlornly empty, except when company came.

That morning, I’m sure, my parents were up early. There were no morning chores to do, so Mom had breakfast ready when Jesse and his family got up. Eggs and toast and gravy and maybe biscuits. She fed them well. My parents may have already eaten by the time Jesse’s family gathered around. Dad was shunning my brother. No eating on the same table. All a bit awkward, yes, but such was the righteousness of his cause. And so they ate, my brother and his wife and children. Mom served her dark rich coffee and asked if anyone wanted cream. And smiled and smiled and fussed.

After breakfast, then, Dad took up his German Bible, and read a passage out loud. And this was the classic time for some admonition. At least when I went home to visit, it was. He had a captive audience. And he’d get all stern, talking about rebellious children, and how their duty is to come back to the church and be obedient. He might have gone a little easier on Jesse’s family, because Lynda was not raised Amish. There was no conceivable possibility that she would ever live that way. Still, he probably felt obligated to say a few words, at least. Just so he wouldn’t be found wanting on Judgment Day. So he could tell the Lord he had done all he knew to do. Ultimately, I think, it’s only fear that could ever drive such a motive.

And then they all knelt for morning prayer, back in 1986. Dad’s voice was still vibrant and strong. And his rhythm was flawless, the same lulling flow of High German we’d always heard, growing up.

And then the day unfolded. Dad had a little barn out by the west barnyard, for his horse. He parked his buggy there, too. And he went out and harnessed his horse and hitched it up. I’m sure it was Kenny, the bony old plug I drove after the Stud died. He brought the rig around to the fence by the walks, and tied up the horse. Mom wanted to do some laundry that morning. The washhouse is between where they are and the house, out of the picture. Dad started the little Honda engine, and Mom got her first load started. And what she’s carrying in that bucket is anyone’s guess. Maybe she was out feeding the chickens, or maybe those are wash pins in there. Who can tell, from this far out?

She was coming in from somewhere. And he was turning from starting the Honda engine, to walk to his buggy. He had business to do, at the phone by the schoolhouse, two miles away. Hardly a week day passed that he didn’t go to the phone at least once. Often more than once. That’s how busy the man always was, absorbed in his business affairs.

And they passed each other on the walks, there. Mom walking in. Dad walking out. And right that second, Jesse was peeking from the kitchen window, his camera aimed. And he snapped a picture.

And that moment, that morning, is now forever frozen in time.

A few words, about that little act that Jesse did. It was a bold thing to do, to snap a picture anywhere on the old home place. This was back in 1986. There were no cell phones with discreet digital cameras back then. If you wanted to take a photo, you had to do it with a real camera. And if Dad had caught anyone taking a pic with a real camera anywhere on his property, well, it would not have been a good thing. There would have been triple admonishing during the next morning’s devotions, probably.

A few other details from that peaceful sunny morning on the old home place in 1986. On the left, you can see the rear of a manure spreader. Not sure why Marvin would have parked it there, unless he was cleaning out the old raggedy barn, further to the left, out of the pic. The barn where I kept the Stud, and where my horse had died. We used to load that spreader by hand, with manure forks, pile it high. And the horses strained into the harness as the machine cut and scattered the manure onto the rich black bottom fields to the south.

And if you look behind the buggy, almost hidden, there sits an old battered Dodge pickup. Henry Egbert was on the farm that morning, for some reason. Maybe Marvin had some hay to haul, or maybe he was going to an auction somewhere. That old pickup had an old trailer attached. That rig right there is how I got my brand-new buggy hauled home from Mr. Mullet’s shop in Milton, a few years before that. It seems so strange, seeing that. Back then, three or four years seemed like a long time. Today, it’s barely a blip in the relentless march of time and history.

And I look at the picture, and I realize. Where I was during the summer of 1986. Out west, on the wheat harvest. Far away, out on the wild buttes of Montana, and then up into Alberta, Canada, driving a gigantic John Deere combine, harvesting acre after waving golden acre of wheat. Under the surface of the scenic calmness of the picture, a lot of troubled water flowed.

And I realize, too. Now. How brutal it must have been, for both Dad and Mom. To keep on walking forward through life, after their sons fled from home like I did so many times.
To face the people they knew were talking behind their backs. David Wagler. He has wild sons. They can’t seem to get settled down. Something is not right, there in that home. It had to be hard to smile at people they knew were thinking and saying such things as that.

Despite his flaws, Dad wanted what was best for his children. And he was willing to sacrifice for what he thought was best. Certainly he would never have left Aylmer for Bloomfield, had that not been the case.

And Mom, heaven only knows how much grief I caused her. I could do penance every day for the rest of my life, and it would never be enough. Ditto for penance for Sarah.

And just thinking, here. It had to be hard for anyone in my family who stayed behind every time I fled. I was running frantically into distant horizons with dark and dangerous skies. Into new lands, new places. Seeing and living new things every day. I left behind me a long and shameful trail of broken promises and shattered dreams.

Someone had to stay behind and pick up all those broken pieces. I look back on it all now, and it’s just unfathomable to me, how selfish so many of my choices were back then. And how I wronged so many people.

And no, I’m not beating myself up. I’m walking back, completely alert, to take a look. To grasp to myself a glimpse. And I’m reflecting on how it was, and how it went, from where I am today.

And today, I am at peace with who I am. And I am at peace with who I was back then.

That’s what the frozen moment from 1986 evokes from the shifting mists of memory and time.



  1. Pictures are like looking into a window of our past. So many things can take us back; feelings, smells and music are like an echo bouncing back but not really there, but a picture is different, we can see it and remember how it was and almost travel back to that moment in our memories.

    Comment by carol ellmore — May 26, 2017 @ 6:41 pm

  2. Ira, great blog. Here are a few thoughts I had on one of my trips back home:

    Quality of Life. When I go back home and go to events like weddings I always marvel at how rapidly the younger generation is moving toward the world. As the religion is handed down from one generation to the next, the younger generation is almost without exception more liberal than the previous. The women’s head covering is an excellent representation of this. The grandmother’s covering will be very far forward on her head covering most of her hair, the mother’s covering will move further back, and usually by the time the granddaughter comes along the covering will be a little circle on the back of the head or will be gone altogether.

    Even though I know this is what occurs, I am still amazed at how rapidly this transformation transpires. I didn’t think I would see the day when the coverings on my nieces would disappear.

    As I attended the last wedding, I had to wonder if this is a good thing?? Is it a good thing for the Amish and Mennonites to become like the world around them? What if there are such things as character, honor, morals, work ethics, principles, and values? Maybe the Amish and Mennonites do a better job of preserving those things that matter. Maybe the Amish and Mennonites have a higher quality of life than the world around them.

    If this is the case, why be in such a hurry to run to the world? In the world you will find an abundance of drunkenness, drug abuse, violence, crime, incarceration, adultery, divorce, broken homes, no family structure, children being born outside of wedlock in ever increasing numbers, children being raised by single parents, children being abused, and children being raised with no morals, values, ethics, or direction.

    Maybe the relevant question is not whether or not the Amish and Mennonite religion is correct or true, but do the Amish and Mennonites experience a higher quality of life than the world around them? For if they do, would it not be better for your children and grandchildren to maintain the traditions and values that can make a difference? Why not maintain the higher quality of life??

    Comment by Ora Stoll — May 26, 2017 @ 6:56 pm

  3. There is so much I don’t understand. I read Ira’s blogs and always feel so??? I appreciate a way of life that attempts to hold values which David Wagler obviously did, but unless these compelling values are accompanied by genuine love, it is all in vain. So many young people have sought other ways because we have failed to include love in our box of tools.

    Comment by OSIAH HORST — May 26, 2017 @ 8:06 pm

  4. Good blog Ira. You put into words the things that most of us ask ourselves but cannot answer.
    God Bless

    Comment by Linda Morris — May 26, 2017 @ 8:25 pm

  5. When I read these blogs I always have such a rush of emotion. Thank you for another great blog, full of love and contrition and honesty.

    Reading the comments that follow, I have a couple of observations. Ora observes the rapid changes in society, and the failure of much of the modern generation to maintain traditions and values their parents and grandparents held to. And then Osiah follows with the remark that unless the values are accompanied by genuine love they are in vain.

    I think that is where the real crux of the matter lies. I’ve always been so fascinated by the Amish culture, but as a born-again Christian I can see where the flaws lie. Compelling people to hold to rules without reason doesn’t change hearts. Christianity is a relationship with God on a personal level, but the Amish do not believe that is possible, and believe it is prideful to claim a personal relationship to Christ. Yet, He came to accomplish that very thing. The harshness of law-keeping was also prevalent during Jesus’ time on earth, by the Jewish leaders of the day. Their condemnation of Jesus and His followers was based on what they saw as a failure to follow the Law, and thus, God. I think that’s how a strict Amish preacher would see it as well. And again, without love, there is no purpose.

    Unfortunately, there is a general rejection of Christian principles by much of today’s youth…not just the Amish. That’s a whole other subject.

    Comment by Jennifer Saks — May 27, 2017 @ 1:39 am

  6. My favorite time of the week…when Ira posts!

    Comment by Gay Racina — May 27, 2017 @ 3:04 am

  7. What you saw in one picture reminds me of a Peanuts cartoon of Lucy, Linus and Charlie Brown looking at cloud formations. I looked at your 1986 photo and I saw two people and horse. You saw years of memories.

    In this cartoon, you’re Linus and I’m Charlie Brown.


    Comment by John Schmid — May 27, 2017 @ 8:19 am

  8. Great post, as usual. I think it’s interesting, looking at the photo, how your Dad’s back is turned away (shunning) from the viewer and your Mom’s isn’t. I know it’s coincidental, but still…..

    Comment by Roxanne — May 27, 2017 @ 11:27 am

  9. My Mom once told me that in her Amish community in Berne, Indiana, they carried out shunning to the next generation. In other words, because my grandparents left the Amish church, this particular group ( I think they were Swartzentruber Amish?) wouldn’t eat with my mom or her siblings even though they hadn’t officially joined the Amish church. That still boggles my mind and reminds me how easy I had it growing up Beachy. Wow. Just wow.

    Comment by Maria Rockhill — May 27, 2017 @ 10:39 pm

  10. Thank you … this blog is eye opening for me. My dad was a very hard driven functioning drunk. Oh the hurt I saw my dear mom endure. The fear ingrained in me as a little girl….it is good to look back and realize I’m me because of him. To know that very fine line between hate and love and knowing love won. I never found it in my earthly father but my Heavenly Father sure taught me love. We press on.

    Comment by Patricia — May 28, 2017 @ 1:49 pm

  11. Old pictures are like a warm cup of tea for the soul. You’ve gained a very healthy adult attitude. The graciousness of a gentleman. Now to strive for happiness as you *live* life openly every day.

    Comment by lisa — May 29, 2017 @ 12:03 am

  12. Compelling people to hold to rules without reason doesn’t change hearts. Christianity is a relationship with God on a personal level, but the Amish do not believe that is possible, and believe it is prideful to claim a personal relationship to Christ… Jennifer Saks; as a born again Amish person I respectfully wish to correct you. There are many Amish people that are born again and believe having a personal relationship with a risen Christ is the only way to heaven.

    You might be right on what you stated about some Amish, but that is not part of my world and also not the way most of the Amish I know believe.

    Comment by Paul H — May 30, 2017 @ 12:05 pm

  13. This blog and the comments are always interesting to me for they are a window into my upbringing and culture that I spent a good part of my life denying and trying to run from.Until I couldnt.And I look at it now,with it’s structure and control and know that the spirit of God as I understand it is not about telling people how to live and dress.Right down to the size of a women’s head covering or whether a married man is allowed to trim his beard.Doesnt make sense to me.If it all makes sense to you,that’s fine.Its none of my business .It’s also none of my business how you worship God.Period.And I’m not going to tell you how I worship God .Unless you ask me.Freedom.Choice.Trust.Honesty.Being teachable.Listening and paying attention to my inner voice.Thats God.For me.God also speaks to me thru my friends and the people around me.Eastern spiritual practices make more sense to me then Western Christianity because those practices bring about a deeper connection to a supreme being.For me.Thats where it’s at along with a deep gratitude…thanks..and peace to all..

    Comment by lenny — June 20, 2017 @ 12:25 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML ( You can use these tags):
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .